Appraisal estimates the costs and benefits of proposed projects
in advance of committing to their delivery, with the aim of establishing
the solution that is most likely to achieve the outcomes sought
from it, at a cost that is proportionate to the gain and is no
more than alternative means of achieving the same objectives, and
at the least risk. Appraisal is also useful for identifying risk
and establishing how best to manage it, including the risks that
arise from over-optimistic assumptions. Appraisal includes:
working up the proposed project to ensure it is deliverable
and will achieve its aims;
comparing the preferred project to other options for achieving
the same objectives; and
appraising all the options on common criteria to establish
which is the most economic, effective and value for money.
Often project appraisals are carried out to support bids or allocations
of public money – including for the project review groups
of Government Departments (CPRG appraisals), Housing Gap Finance
and ERDF grant (which also requires a business plan).
Examples of our project appraisals include :
the Jubilee Line Extension; the Lambton Coke Works, Weetslade
Colliery, and Carr Lodge National Coalfield Programme projects;
the prime office core proposed by the Leicester Masterplan (which
RTP also prepared); Island Wharf in Hull (the first phase of
Humber Quays, one of the major projects in the Hull City Centre
Masterplan which RTP also prepared); a publicly assisted hotel
development at Speke Garston in Liverpool; and the New Islington
Millennium Community;
Project appraisals to support successful bids for major grants include:
the Salford Quays and Eccles extensions of Metrolink, the Imperial
War Museum North and the Bridgewater hall in Manchester, all of which
included full cost benefit analyses and business plans; the Clyde
Waterfront Regeneration Initiative; and a major business park in
Torbay.
Islington NRF Evaluation -
Evaluation on the effectiveness and value for money of Neighbourhood Renewal Fund in the
borough.
Imperial War Museum North - Evaluation of the site options for the project across the north of England.
Glasgow Harbour Economic Impact Appraisal - An Economic Impact Appraisal of the funding investment into the Glasgow Harbour development
at Finnieston – Clydeside.